We at the PiRate Ratings have realized that the public can find much more accurate bracketology data than that provided by the famous bracketologists at the major media outlets. We have known this because as regular annual participants in the Football Prediction Tracker, you don’t see the most famous computer ranking services finishing at the top. Looking at this week’s Basketball Prediction Tracker record of picking winning teams (http://www.thepredictiontracker.com/bbresults.php), you will see that it is our new experimental PiRate White and PiRate Red rankings that sit at number one and number two at 77.2% and 76.5%. It’s always some math genius, sports fan professor of mathematics at some university (or somebody like us who got lucky and finished first twice before).
Bracketology is not an exact science. There is no sabermetric formula you can plug into a computer and spit out the 68 teams that should be selected for the tournament. There is no Batter’s Wins, Pitcher’s Wins, and Fielding Wins that show you the Mike Trout’s of college basketball.
Instead, we have smart guys like Patrick Stevens of the Syracuse Post-Standard newspaper, who for several years has been putting out bracketology selections considerably more accurate than the famous gurus at the major outlets. Stevens is not alone. We have isolated more than two dozen bracketologists with five or more years experience that all dust the major competition in accuracy.
When you combine these less known but more accurate hard-working guys, their composite selections are about as accurate as you will find anywhere. For instance, two years ago, a couple successfully selected all 68 teams, and the rest picked 66 or 67 teams out of 68 correctly. As a combined group, the composite successfully picked all 68 teams correctly. Last year, the group as a whole hit on 67 of 68.
We first became interested in finding a more accurate bracketology experience when most of the gurus failed to select Virginia Commonwealth to make the Big Dance in 2011, and the Rams merely advanced to the Final Four. One of the big-time selectors failed to include Dayton in last year’s predictions, and the Flyers advanced to the Elite 8.
And so, continuing today and appearing frequently until Selection Sunday, we will monitor our 20-something unknown Einsteins and keep what we call the PiRate Composite Bracketology rankings.
Report for Monday, February 09, 2015
Let’s begin with the one-bid leagues. 21 conferences will send just one team to the NCAA Tournament. In the case of 20 of these 21, the conference tournament winner will receive that lone bid.
The Ivy League may never hold a dedicated conference tournament, but many times in the past, a post-season playoff for first place has given the league a quasi-tournament. In the Ivy, any team finishing tied for first qualifies for a playoff, even if one of the co-champs swept the other in the regular season. Harvard and Yale could very well play in March to determine the league champ.
For the one bid leagues, we will name the top contenders at the present time based on conference won-lost record.
America East | Conference | Overall |
Albany | 11-0 | 16-7 |
Vermont | 9-2 | 14-10 |
New Hampshire | 7-4 | 14-10 |
Stony Brook | 6-4 | 15-10 |
Atlantic Sun | Conference | Overall |
Florida Gulf Coast | 7-1 | 17-7 |
North Florida | 7-1 | 15-10 |
USC Upstate | 5-3 | 18-7 |
Big Sky | Conference | Overall |
Sacramento St. | 10-1 | 16-6 |
Eastern Washington | 9-1 | 18-5 |
Montana | 8-3 | 12-10 |
Northern Arizona | 7-3 | 12-11 |
Northern Colorado | 7-4 | 12-10 |
Big South | Conference | Overall |
High Point | 8-4 | 17-7 |
Coastal Carolina | 8-4 | 17-7 |
Radford | 8-4 | 17-8 |
Gardner-Webb | 8-4 | 16-9 |
Charleston Southern | 8-4 | 14-9 |
Winthrop | 8-4 | 13-10 |
UNC Asheville | 8-4 | 12-11 |
Big West | Conference | Overall |
UC Davis | 8-1 | 18-4 |
UC Irvine | 7-2 | 14-9 |
Long Beach St. | 7-2 | 13-12 |
Colonial | Conference | Overall |
William & Mary | 9-3 | 15-8 |
Northeastern | 8-4 | 16-9 |
UNC Wilmington | 8-4 | 13-10 |
Hofstra | 7-5 | 16-9 |
James Madison | 7-5 | 14-11 |
Drexel | 7-5 | 9-14 |
Conference USA | Conference | Overall |
Louisiana Tech | 9-2 | 18-6 |
Western Kentucky | 9-2 | 16-7 |
U A B | 9-2 | 13-11 |
U T E P | 8-3 | 16-7 |
Old Dominion | 7-3 | 18-4 |
UT San Antonio | 6-5 | 12-10 |
Middle Tennessee | 6-5 | 13-11 |
Horizon | Conference | Overall |
Valparaiso | 9-2 | 22-4 |
Cleveland St. | 9-2 | 15-10 |
Green Bay | 8-2 | 19-5 |
Oakland | 7-3 | 12-13 |
Ivy League | Conference | Overall |
Harvard | 5-1 | 15-5 |
Yale | 5-1 | 16-7 |
Princeton | 3-2 | 10-11 |
Columbia | 3-3 | 11-9 |
Cornell | 3-3 | 11-11 |
M A C | Conference | Overall |
Bowling Green | 7-3 | 15-6 |
Akron | 7-3 | 16-7 |
Kent St. | 7-3 | 16-7 |
Toledo | 7-3 | 15-8 |
Central Michigan | 6-4 | 16-5 |
Buffalo | 6-4 | 15-7 |
Western Michigan | 5-5 | 14-9 |
M A A C | Conference | Overall |
Iona | 11-2 | 18-6 |
Rider | 10-4 | 16-9 |
Manhattan | 9-5 | 12-11 |
Monmouth | 9-5 | 13-12 |
M E A C | Conference | Overall |
UNC Central | 10-0 | 18-6 |
Norfolk St. | 9-1 | 16-9 |
Howard | 6-3 | 12-11 |
UM-Eastern Shore | 6-4 | 13-12 |
South Carolina St. | 6-4 | 9-16 |
Northeast | Conference | Overall |
St. Francis (NY) | 10-2 | 16-9 |
Robert Morris | 8-4 | 12-12 |
Bryant | 8-4 | 11-12 |
St. Francis (PA) | 7-5 | 13-10 |
Mt. St. Mary‘s | 7-5 | 11-12 |
Ohio Valley | Conference | Overall |
Murray St. | 11-0 | 21-4 |
Tenn-Martin | 7-3 | 15-8 |
Belmont | 7-4 | 15-9 |
Eastern Illinois | 7-4 | 14-10 |
Morehead St. | 7-4 | 12-14 |
Eastern Kentucky | 6-4 | 14-9 |
Patriot | Conference | Overall |
Bucknell | 8-4 | 13-12 |
Colgate | 8-4 | 11-14 |
Lehigh | 7-5 | 13-10 |
Lafayette | 6-5 | 14-8 |
Southern | Conference | Overall |
Wofford | 11-1 | 20-5 |
Chattanooga | 9-3 | 16-9 |
Mercer | 9-3 | 14-11 |
Western Carolina | 7-6 | 12-13 |
Southland | Conference | Overall |
Stephen F. Austin | 9-0 | 19-3 |
Sam Houston St. | 10-1 | 18-5 |
Northwestern St. | 7-3 | 12-9 |
Texas A&M-C.C. | 7-3 | 12-10 |
Summit | Conference | Overall |
North Dakota St. | 9-2 | 17-7 |
South Dakota St. | 9-3 | 18-8 |
Oral Roberts | 6-4 | 13-11 |
I P F W | 6-5 | 13-11 |
Sun Belt | Conference | Overall |
La. Monroe | 10-3 | 16-8 |
Georgia Southern | 9-3 | 16-5 |
Georgia St. | 9-4 | 16-8 |
UT-Arlington | 7-5 | 13-9 |
La. Lafayette | 7-6 | 13-11 |
S W A C | Conference | Overall |
Texas Southern | 8-2 | 11-12 |
Jackson St. | 5-5 | 7-16 |
Prairie View | 5-5 | 7-16 |
Alabama A&M | 5-5 | 6-14 |
W A C | Conference | Overall |
New Mexico St. | 7-1 | 15-10 |
U M K C | 5-3 | 10-15 |
Seattle | 4-4 | 11-11 |
The remaining 11 conferences will divvy up the 47 remaining bids. For these conferences, we will list the teams by the average seed given to them by our two dozen plus experts. If an expert left a team off his list, we assign a seed of “20” to this team to lower their overall seeding. Thus, it is better to be the last team in the Big Dance on every bracketologist’s list and seeded at 13 than to be a 12-seed on 80% and not included on 20%.
American | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Tulsa | 10-1 | 17-6 | 12 |
SMU | 10-2 | 19-5 | 7 |
Cincinnati | 8-3 | 17-6 | 7 |
Temple | 8-3 | 17-7 | 13 |
Memphis | 6-4 | 14-9 | Out |
Connecticut | 6-4 | 13-9 | Out |
Atlantic 10 | Conference | Overall | Seed |
V C U | 8-2 | 18-5 | 5 |
Rhode Island | 8-2 | 16-5 | Bubble |
Dayton | 7-3 | 17-5 | 10 |
George Washington | 7-3 | 17-6 | 1st out |
U Mass | 7-3 | 14-9 | 8th out |
Davidson | 6-4 | 15-6 | Bubble |
St. Bonaventure | 6-4 | 13-8 | Out |
A C C | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Virginia | 9-1 | 21-1 | 1 |
Notre Dame | 9-3 | 21-4 | 4 |
North Carolina | 8-3 | 18-6 | 3 |
Duke | 7-3 | 20-3 | 1 |
Louisville | 7-3 | 19-4 | 3 |
Clemson | 6-5 | 14-9 | 7th out |
Pittsburgh | 5-5 | 16-8 | Bubble |
Miami (FL) | 5-5 | 15-8 | 13 |
N.C. State | 5-6 | 14-10 | 6th out |
Big East | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Villanova | 8-2 | 21-2 | 2 |
Butler | 8-3 | 18-6 | 5 |
Providence | 7-4 | 17-7 | 6 |
Georgetown | 7-5 | 15-8 | 7 |
Xavier | 6-6 | 15-9 | 9 |
DePaul | 6-6 | 12-13 | Out |
Seton Hall | 5-6 | 15-8 | 12 |
St. John’s | 4-6 | 15-8 | 12 |
Big Ten | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Wisconsin | 9-1 | 21-2 | 2 |
Maryland | 7-4 | 19-5 | 4 |
Ohio St. | 7-4 | 18-6 | 8 |
Indiana | 7-4 | 17-7 | 7 |
Purdue | 7-4 | 15-9 | 4th out |
Iowa | 6-4 | 15-8 | 8 |
Michigan St. | 6-4 | 15-8 | 11 |
Illinois | 6-5 | 16-8 | 11 |
Michigan | 6-6 | 13-11 | Bubble |
Minnesota | 4-7 | 15-9 | Bubble |
Big 12 | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Kansas | 8-2 | 19-4 | 2 |
Iowa St. | 7-3 | 17-5 | 3 |
Oklahoma | 7-4 | 16-7 | 4 |
Baylor | 6-4 | 18-5 | 3 |
West Virginia | 6-4 | 18-5 | 6 |
Oklahoma St. | 6-5 | 16-7 | 6 |
Kansas St. | 5-6 | 12-12 | Out |
Texas | 4-6 | 15-8 | 8 |
Missouri Valley | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Northern Iowa | 11-1 | 22-2 | 5 |
Wichita St. | 11-1 | 21-3 | 5 |
Mountain West | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Wyoming | 8-3 | 19-5 | 10th out |
San Diego St. | 8-3 | 18-6 | 9 |
Boise St. | 7-3 | 17-6 | 5th out |
Colorado St. | 7-4 | 20-4 | 9 |
Pac-12 | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Arizona | 8-2 | 20-3 | 2 |
Utah | 8-2 | 18-4 | 4 |
Oregon | 7-4 | 17-7 | 3rd out |
Oregon St. | 7-4 | 16-7 | Out |
Stanford | 7-4 | 16-7 | 10 |
U C L A | 6-5 | 14-10 | 2nd out |
Washington | 3-8 | 14-9 | Bubble |
S E C | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Kentucky | 10-0 | 23-0 | 1 |
Arkansas | 7-3 | 18-5 | 6 |
Texas A&M | 7-3 | 16-6 | 10 |
Ole Miss | 7-3 | 16-7 | 9 |
L S U | 6-4 | 17-6 | 10 |
Georgia | 6-4 | 15-7 | 8 |
Tennessee | 5-5 | 13-9 | Bubble |
Florida | 5-5 | 12-11 | 9th out |
Alabama | 4-6 | 14-9 | Bubble |
West Coast | Conference | Overall | Seed |
Gonzaga | 12-0 | 24-1 | 1 |
Saint Mary’s | 10-2 | 18-5 | Bubble |
B Y U | 8-5 | 18-8 | Bubble |
Pepperdine | 8-5 | 15-9 | Out |
Using the average seeding of all the teams, here is how the experts see the top four seeds per region as of today.
South | Seed |
Kentucky | 1 |
Arizona | 2 |
Louisville | 3 |
Maryland | 4 |
East | Seed |
Virginia | 1 |
Villanova | 2 |
Iowa St. | 3 |
Oklahoma | 4 |
Midwest | Seed |
Duke | 1 |
Kansas | 2 |
North Carolina | 3 |
Utah | 4 |
West | Seed |
Gonzaga | 1 |
Wisconsin | 2 |
Baylor | 3 |
Notre Dame | 4 |
This is how our experts seed the eight teams that must play an opening round game in Dayton. This includes the last four teams making the NCAA Tournament as #12 or #13 seeds as well as the lowest four-seeded teams among those that receive automatic bids.
Opening Round Games at Dayton |
Miami (FL.) vs. St. John’s |
Temple vs. Seton Hall |
America East Champion vs. Patriot Champion |
S W A C Champion vs. Northeast Champion |
How about the top five teams from conferences that will receive just one bid? There are five teams seen as capable of beating a higher seed, including one team deemed to be talented enough to sneak into the Sweet 16.
Top 5 Teams From 1-bid Leagues | |
Old Dominion | Sweet 16 |
Stephen F. Austin | 1 win |
Louisiana Tech | 1 win |
Valparaiso | 1 win |
Murray St. | 1 win |
So you want some dark horse candidates to sneak into the Final Four. Here are four teams that have qualities that can make it hard for opponents to prepare to play on short notice. This is a quartet of teams that could make an unexpected run to the Final Four.
4 Darkhorse Final 4 Candidates |
Indiana |
Iowa St. |
Northern Iowa |
Utah |
Every year, a top-6 seed loses its opening round game in such a way that it really does not look like an upset. In the past Georgetown and Vanderbilt have lost multiple times to double-digit seeds in such a way that the underdog looked like it could win nine times out of 10. Here are the teams this season most vulnerable to losing a first round game as the favorite, while looking like they might lose nine times out of 10 to the “upset” winner.
5 1st Round Upset Candidates |
Arkansas |
Maryland |
Notre Dame |
Oklahoma St. |
Villanova |
Congratulations to Georgetown! The Hoyas appear to have the talent to win that first round game this year.
Here are the 10 most vulnerable at-large teams this week. A couple of unexpected losses or too many unexpected losses will send these teams to the NIT.
Last 10 IN | Overall Seed |
Miami (FL) | 68 |
Temple | 67 |
Seton Hall | 66 |
St. John’s | 65 |
Tulsa | 64 |
Michigan St. | 63 |
Illinois | 62 |
Texs A&M | 61 |
L S U | 60 |
Stanford | 59 |
Here are the top 10 teams waiting to move up into the field if and when some of the last 10 flub up. These teams are one winning steak or a big win or two away from moving into the field of 68.
1st 10 Out | Overall Seed |
George Washington | 69 |
U C L A | 70 |
Oregon | 71 |
Purdue | 72 |
Boise St. | 73 |
N. C. St. | 74 |
Clemson | 75 |
U Mass | 76 |
Florida | 77 |
Wyoming | 78 |
We will have another update next Monday, February 16. It won’t be long until the first conference tournaments commence. Three weeks from tomorrow, the Atlantic Sun, Horizon, and Patriot League tournaments start.
We will have the conference tournament seeds and score updates daily starting with Monday, March 2.