The Pi-Rate Ratings

August 10, 2018

2018 Sun Belt Conference Preview

Welcome to the 2018 College Football season! It has been a long Winter, Spring, and Summer in dry dock, but the PiRates have fixed the ship up better than new, and we are anxious to launch our repaired vessel to the Gridiron Sea for 2018-19.

If you read yesterday’s post, we took on a remodeling job with our ratings this year. New analytical data became available to convince us that we needed to tweak the weighting we gave each position on the field, more in the NFL, but still a great deal in the NCAA. Thus, some schools that may have been ranked in the top 25 to start the season did not climb out of the 30’s, while one or two schools that may have faced what we thought might have been rebuilding seasons stayed in the top 25. We will know soon how well the new system fares. The advanced statistics should be more accurate if history holds up, but the sample size is still small enough that some increased standard deviation and variance could give us some nervous Saturdays in September. By the first of October, the ratings should be about the same as they would be if we kept the old algorithms.

Before we start with out first preview, let us notify you that the preseason ratings you see in the previews may not be the same as the ratings you see for the first game. We update every team’s rating based on player injuries, changes to the depth charts, and other factors that may change during preseason practice. Of course, we also have two major stories that will force us to alter the ratings before week one–What happens with Urban Meyer at Ohio State, and how many players from North Carolina will not dress for the California game in Berkeley.

With our ratings, the total average for the 130 teams must be 100.0, so if we remove 10 points from one school and 7 points from another, those lost 17 points have to be redistributed to the other 128 teams. It isn’t as easy as that, because upwards of 40 schools will need to have their opening week ratings lowered due to the high number of roster adjustments in August, and the remaining 90 schools will then pick up fractions of a point to as much as a couple of points.

Now that the preliminary announcements have been made, let’s start with this year’s first conference preview. Bringing up the rear yet again is the Sun Belt Conference, which ranks 11th out of 11 leagues in FBS power rating.

The SBC has changed quite a bit in 2018. Idaho left the conference and FBS football, as the Vandals dropped to FCS. New Mexico State left to become an independent just one year after breaking a string of 14 consecutive losing seasons and celebrating their first bowl win since 1960.

There are now 10 teams in the Sun Belt Conference, but the league has now split into two divisions, and there will be a conference championship game on December 1st.

Last year, Appalachian State and Troy tied for the league championship, with Arkansas State, Georgia State, and former member New Mexico State joining the co-champions in bowl games. Troy won with their defense and a strong passing game, while Appy State won with their balanced offense and tough pass defense.

Here is how the SBC media voted in the preseason poll.

Team Votes
East Division 1st Place Overall
1. Appalachian State 6 46
2. Troy 4 44
3. Georgia State 0 26
4. Georgia Southern 0 22
5. Coastal Carolina 0 12
West Division 1st Place Overall
1. Arkansas St. 9 49
2. Louisiana-Monroe 0 37
3. South Alabama 1 26
4. Louisiana 0 25
5. Texas State 0 13

There were no votes for overall conference champion.

The PiRate Ratings are a tad different to begin the 2018 season. They agree with the media all up and down in the West Division, but the East is different at the top, where Troy begins the season ranked ahead of Appy State, and Georgia Southern leads Georgia State at the beginning of the season.

East Division
Team SBC Overall PiRate Mean Bias Average
Troy 0-0 0-0 91.8 93.7 93.7 93.1
Appalachian St. 0-0 0-0 87.5 89.1 88.7 88.4
Georgia Southern 0-0 0-0 82.5 83.7 82.4 82.9
Georgia St. 0-0 0-0 77.6 80.6 78.4 78.9
Coastal Carolina 0-0 0-0 73.2 76.4 73.6 74.4
West Division
Team SBC Overall PiRate Mean Bias Average
Arkansas St. 0-0 0-0 88.0 89.8 89.7 89.2
UL-Monroe 0-0 0-0 87.3 86.7 88.1 87.4
South Alabama 0-0 0-0 81.4 83.8 82.6 82.6
Louisiana 0-0 0-0 78.9 81.1 79.9 80.0
Texas State 0-0 0-0 70.4 73.9 69.9 71.4
Sun Belt Averages 81.9 83.9 82.7 82.8

New Coaches
Georgia Southern elevated Chad Lunsford from interim coach to full-time head coach, and Lunsford will move the Eagles back to the option/zone read offense that former coach Willie Fritz used when GSU went 8-4 and played in the GoDaddy.com Bowl. Lunsford assumed head coaching duties last year when Georgia Southern began the year 0-6 and averaging just 18 points per game. Under Lunsford, the team finished 2-4 and averaged 23.7 points per game. Expect the Eagles to top 25 points per game and approach 28 to 30 this year.

Louisiana begins the Billy Napier era in Lafayette. Napier has an impressive resume that includes working for Dabo Swinney and Nick Saban. He most recently served as offensive coordinator at Arizona State, where the Sun Devils averaged 31.8 yards and 431 yards per game. Napier was offered to remain in Tempe as the offensive coordinator under Coach Herm Edwards, but he took the job in Lafayette instead.

South Alabama welcomes Steve Campbell to Ladd-Peebles Stadium. Campbell enjoyed an outstanding four-year stint at FCS Central Arkansas. He led the Bears to a 33-15 record including back-to-back 10-win seasons and FCS Playoff bids. Campbell served as the offensive line coach at Mississippi State for one season and as offensive coordinator at Middle Tennessee for one season as his only paid FBS coaching experience. He was also a graduate assistant under Pat Dye at Auburn.

Predicted Won-Loss Records

East
Team Conference Overall
Troy 8-0 11-2*
Appalachian St. 6-2 9-3
Georgia Southern 4-4 6-6
Georgia St. 2-6 3-9
Coastal Carolina 0-8 1-11
West
Team Conference Overall
Arkansas St. 8-0 10-3
UL-Monroe 6-2 7-5
Louisiana 4-4 6-6
South Alabama 2-6 3-9
Texas St. 0-8 1-11
* Troy picked to win SBC Championship Game

Bowl Tie-ins
The SBC does not have a set bowl order. They send eligible teams to bowls to create the best overall games. These are the bowls tie-ins for 2018.

Arizona Bowl in Tucson, AZ
Camellia Bowl in Montgomery, AL
Cure Bowl in Orlando, FL
Dollar General Bowl in Mobile, AL
New Orleans Bowl in New Orleans, LA

Coming Tomorrow–Conference USA

Advertisements

August 15, 2016

2016 Sun Belt Conference Football Ratings Preview

The PiRate Ratings kick off its 2016 college football coverage today with the first of 11 previews. We will preview conferences in order of lowest overall average rating to highest, so as we have every year since this league’s inception, we begin with the Sun Belt Conference today.

Last year, Arkansas State ventured to Appalachian State to decide the conference championship in early November. Both teams were undefeated in conference play at the time, and Appy State was a 10-point home favorite. The Mountaineers led 21-14 just before the half, but the Red Wolves scored 26 straight points and won 40-27 and ran the table to finish 8-0 in the league.

This year, the same two teams, plus third place Georgia Southern will contend for the 2016 SBC crown. The PiRates believe four additional teams will compete for bowl eligibility, with three becoming successful, and four teams will try to stay out of the basement and go winless in the league, and possibly winless overall.

With the more favorable FBS vs. FCS schedules this year, it is our opinion that considerably more than the needed teams will be bowl eligible, so this league is likely to see at least one team end the season bowl eligible and not receive a bowl invitation.

Here is how the Sun Belt Media predicted the order of finish in the pre-season media roundup.

2016 Sun Belt Conference Media Poll
# Team 1st Pl. Total
1 Appalachian St. 5 114
2 Arkansas St. 5 110
3 Georgia Southern 1 98
4 Georgia St. 0 73
5t UL-Lafayette 0 70
5t Troy 0 70
7 South Alabama 0 62
8 Idaho 0 48
9 New Mexico St. 0 37
10 Texas St. 0 30
11 UL-Monroe 0 14

The Beginning PiRate Numbers differ very little from the official poll.

Sunbelt Conference
Team PiRate Mean Bias Average
Appalachian St. 95.5 95.7 97.1 96.1
Arkansas St. 91.9 94.2 94.4 93.5
Georgia Southern 93.0 91.7 95.5 93.4
Troy 83.6 90.2 85.2 86.4
Georgia St. 81.7 87.1 83.9 84.2
Idaho 78.1 85.2 79.7 81.0
UL-Lafayette 76.3 86.8 78.7 80.6
South Alabama 75.3 85.2 76.2 78.9
New Mexico St. 73.7 76.5 74.9 75.0
UL-Monroe 67.9 73.3 68.3 69.8
Texas St. 68.8 69.5 69.5 69.3
         
Sun Belt Averages 80.5 85.1 82.1 82.6

The PiRate Ratings are best used just to look forward to the next week game schedule.  These ratings cannot really be used to predict won-loss records, so with that caveat, here are the projected won-loss records based on the ratings above.

Sun Belt Conference Projected Standings
Team Conference Overall Bowl
Arkansas St. 8-0 9-3 New Orleans
Appalachian St. 7-1 9-3 GoDaddy
Georgia Southern 7-1 8-4 Cammelia
Troy 5-3 7-5 Cure
UL-Lafayette 5-3 6-6 [Independence] *
Idaho 5-3 6-6 Bowl Eligible
Georgia St. 3-5 5-7
South Alabama 2-6 3-9
UL-Monroe 1-7 2-10
New Mexico St. 1-7 1-11
Texas St. 0-8 1-11

*  This is an at-large bowl bid

Next Preview: Tuesday, August 16–Conference USA

August 15, 2013

2013 Sunbelt Conference Football Preview

2013 Sunbelt Conference Preview

 

Once again, the Sunbelt Conference kicks off our PiRate Ratings Previews for a new college football season.  We preview the conferences in reverse order of overall league average, and the SBC brings up the rear once again.  Whereas in past seasons, this league was not that far behind its non-automatic-qualifying conference brethren, changes due to defections and new additions have damaged the league.

New Teams: Georgia State and Texas State

Departed Teams: Florida Atlantic, Florida International, Middle Tennessee, North Texas

2014 Additions: New Mexico St. and Idaho return to the league they left after 2003, while FCS teams Appalachian St. and Georgia Southern move to FBS

2014 Departures: Western Kentucky moves to CUSA

 

Pre-season PiRate Ratings

Sunbelt Conference

Team

Conf.

Overall

PiRate

Mean

Bias

Louisiana—Monroe

0-0

0-0

96.8

93.0

98.0

Arkansas St.

0-0

0-0

93.6

87.6

93.5

Louisiana—Lafayette

0-0

0-0

92.4

91.6

92.2

Western Kentucky

0-0

0-0

89.5

93.5

90.3

Troy

0-0

0-0

85.5

87.0

87.1

Texas St.

0-0

0-0

80.6

87.8

79.9

South Alabama

0-0

0-0

79.9

82.7

80.5

Georgia St.

0-0

0-0

60.7

71.5

62.1

     

 

 

 

League Averages    

84.9

86.8

85.5

 

Official Sunbelt Media Poll

 

     

Pos.

Team

Points

1st Place

 

     

1 (tie)

Louisiana-Lafayette

57

4

 

     

1 (tie)

Louisiana-Monroe

57

2

 

     

3

Arkansas St.

45

2

 

     

4

Western Kentucky

44

0

 

     

5

Troy

35

0

 

     

6

Texas St.

23

0

 

     

7

South Alabama

19

0

 

     

8

Georgia St.

8

0

 

 

 

 

Official Pre-season All-Sunbelt Conference Team

Offense
Kolton Browning (Louisiana-Monroe, Sr., QB)
David Oku (Arkansas State, Sr., RB)
Antonio Andrews (WKU, Sr., RB)
J.D. McKissic (Arkansas State, So., WR)
Je’Ron Hamm (ULM, Sr., WR)
Eric Thomas (Troy, Sr. WR)
Wes Saxton (South Alabama, Jr., TE)
Bryce Giddens (Arkansas State, So., OL)
Andre Huval (Louisiana-Lafayette, Sr., OL)
Josh Allen (Louisiana-Monroe, Sr., OL)
Terrence Jones (Troy, Jr., OL)
Sean Conway (WKU, Sr., OL)
 
Defense
Ryan Carrethers (Arkansas State, Sr., DL)
Christian Ringo (Louisiana-Lafayette, Jr., DL)
Kentarius Caldwell (Louisiana-Monroe, Sr., DL)
Alex Page (South Alabama, Sr., DL)
Qushaun Lee (Arkansas State, Jr., LB)
Justin Anderson (Louisiana-Lafayette, Sr., LB)
Andrew Jackson (WKU, Jr., LB)
Sterling Young (Arkansas State, Jr., DB)
Isaiah Newsome (Louisiana-Monroe, Sr., DB)
Tyrell Pearson (South Alabama, Sr., DB)
Jonathan Dowling (WKU, Sr., DB)
 
Special Teams
Brian Davis (Arkansas State, Sr., K)
Will Scott (Troy, Sr., P)
Antonio Andrews (WKU, Sr., Return Specialist)
 
Preseason Offensive Player of the Year
Kolton Browning (Louisiana-Monroe, Sr., QB)
 
Preseason Defensive Player of the Year
Andrew Jackson (WKU, Jr., LB)

 

 

PiRate Ratings Summary

 

About Grades

93-100    A+

86-92      A

79-85      A-

72-78      B+

65-71      B

58-64      B-

51-57      C+

44-50      C

37-43      C-

30-36      D

0-29        F

 

About Predictions

Predictions are based on the PiRate Ratings with home field advantage factored in.  The PiRate Ratings use different home field advantages for every game, since the opponent factors into the equation.

 

Team

UL-Monroe Warhawks

             
Head Coach

Todd Berry

             
Colors

Maroon & Gold

             
City

Monroe, LA

             
2012 Record            
Conference

6-2

Overall

8-5

             
Grades            
Run Offense

57

Pass Offense

76

Run Defense

62

Pass Defense

51

             
Ratings              
PiRate

96.8

Mean

93.0

Bias

98.0

             
Rankings              
PiRate

76

Mean

90

Bias

72

               
Prediction              
Conference

6-1

Overall

8-4

Team

Arkansas State Red Wolves

             
Head Coach

Bryan Harsin

             
Colors

Scarlet & Black

             
City

Jonesboro, AR

             
2012 Record            
Conference

7-1

Overall

10-3

             
Grades            
Run Offense

67

Pass Offense

67

Run Defense

52

Pass Defense

49

             
Ratings              
PiRate

93.6

Mean

87.6

Bias

93.5

             
Rankings              
PiRate

83

Mean

108

Bias

84

               
Prediction              
Conference

6-1

Overall

9-3

Team

Louisiana-Lafayette Ragin’ Cajuns

             
Head Coach

Mark Hudspeth

             
Colors

Vermillion and White

             
City

Lafayette, LA

             
2012 Record            
Conference

6-2

Overall

9-4

             
Grades            
Run Offense

67

Pass Offense

71

Run Defense

49

Pass Defense

43

             
Ratings              
PiRate

92.4

Mean

91.6

Bias

92.2

             
Rankings              
PiRate

87

Mean

98

Bias

88

               
Prediction              
Conference

5-2

Overall

8-4

Team

Western Kentucky Hilltoppers

             
Head Coach

Bobby Petrino

             
Colors

Red and White

             
City

Bowling Green, KY

             
2012 Record            
Conference

4-4

Overall

7-6

             
Grades            
Run Offense

53

Pass Offense

60

Run Defense

48

Pass Defense

55

             
Ratings              
PiRate

89.5

Mean

93.5

Bias

90.3

             
Rankings              
PiRate

93

Mean

89

Bias

93

               
Prediction              
Conference

5-2

Overall

8-4

Team

Troy Trojans

             
Head Coach

Larry Blakeney

             
Colors

Red, Black, and Gray

             
City

Troy, AL

             
2012 Record            
Conference

3-5

Overall

5-7

             
Grades            
Run Offense

36

Pass Offense

72

Run Defense

41

Pass Defense

47

             
Ratings              
PiRate

85.5

Mean

87.0

Bias

87.1

             
Rankings              
PiRate

106

Mean

109

Bias

99

               
Prediction              
Conference

3-4

Overall

4-8

Team

Texas State Bobcats

             
Head Coach

Dennis Franchione

             
Colors

Maroon and Gold

             
City

San Marcos, TX

             
2012 Record            
Conference

2-4 (in WAC)

Overall

4-8

             
Grades            
Run Offense

52

Pass Offense

38

Run Defense

57

Pass Defense

40

             
Ratings              
PiRate

80.6

Mean

87.8

Bias

79.9

             
Rankings              
PiRate

117

Mean

106

Bias

118

               
Prediction              
Conference

2-5

Overall

4-8

Team

South Alabama Jaguars

             
Head Coach

Joey Jones

             
Colors

Red, White, and Blue

             
City

Mobile, AL

             
2012 Record            
Conference

1-7

Overall

2-11

             
Grades            
Run Offense

50

Pass Offense

46

Run Defense

46

Pass Defense

39

             
Ratings              
PiRate

79.9

Mean

82.7

Bias

80.5

             
Rankings              
PiRate

118

Mean

119

Bias

116

               
Prediction              
Conference

1-6

Overall

2-10

Team

Georgia State Panthers

             
Head Coach

Trent Miles

             
Colors

Royal Blue and White

             
City

Atlanta

             
2012 Record            
Conference

1-7 (in FCS:Colonial Athletic)

Overall

1-10

             
Grades            
Run Offense

17

Pass Offense

35

Run Defense

31

Pass Defense

19

             
Ratings              
PiRate

60.7

Mean

71.5

Bias

62.1

             
Rankings              
PiRate

125

Mean

125

Bias

125

               
Prediction              
Conference

0-7

Overall

0-12

Blog at WordPress.com.