PiRate Ratings For NFL Football: Week 7–October 24-25, 2010

A PiRate Look at the Playoff Chase

Parity, shmarity!  12 and only 12 teams will make the playoffs, and 20 teams will not regardless of how close the 32 teams might be in talent.  How do we look for the playoff teams? 

We wish we could tell you we have a great formula like we have for picking the NCAA Basketball Tournament.  If you want to read about that, click on the College Basketball link on the right side of the page and read up on how successful our tournament formula has been in the past. 

The only tell-tale sign in back-testing that is worth a grain of salt is scoring margin.  Teams with scoring margins over 10 points per game have historically dominated in the playoffs.  At this point of the season, it is too early to use scoring margin due to a small sampling of games.  After 16 games, the strengths of schedule differ much less, but after six games, the margin is too much.

 

Let’s try to look at the divisions strictly by how well the teams appear to be playing. 

NFC East

 

Dallas can forget hosting the Super Bowl.  They won’t make the playoffs this season.  The Giants and Eagles have yet to play each other, but we feel like Philadelphia is a little better at this point and believe the Eagles will soar above the rest in the East.  New York will stay in the playoff race.  Washington looks like an 8-8 team. 

NFC North

 

Green Bay’s injury problems have left this division race open for three teams.  Minnesota should begin to play better offensively as Randy Moss gets more and more acclimated to his old digs.  Chicago appears to be lacking the offensive line strength to win 10 games.  The Bears could be 9-7 or 8-8, and we think 9-7 will not be enough to qualify as a Wildcard.  As for the Packers, it is going to be tough relying strictly on the passing game when the weather turns frigid.  We think Minnesota will win the North with a 10-6 record. 

NFC South

 

As soon as Tampa Bay proves to be unworthy of playoff mention, this will become a two-team race between Atlanta and New Orleans.  They could finish in a tie, with the tiebreaker loser gaining a Wildcard spot.  We think both could finish 11-5. 

NFC West

 

It has never happened before, but there is a chance it could happen this year.  No division winner has ever been 8-8 or worse, but it could happen in this division.  Arizona and San Francisco have little on offense, while Seattle and St. Louis have so much young and inconsistent talent.  If we had to pick one team to go 9-7, it would be Pete Carroll’s Seahawks. 

AFC East

 

With Buffalo primed to go 2-14 or worse and probably go 0-6 in division play, it allows the other three teams to clean up in the standings.  The Jets look like the class of the league at this point of the season, but they are not dominant yet.  New England is solid, while Miami has enough talent to stay in the playoff picture.  We will call for the Jets to win the division at 12-4 or 13-3 with the Patriots in the Wildcard picture at 11-5 or 12-4.  As for Miami, the Dolphins will stay in the hunt for most of the season before settling in at 9-7. 

AFC North

Pittsburgh and Baltimore are as strong collectively as the Jets and Patriots.  We feel strongly that both teams will make the playoffs with records in the 12-4 range.  Cincinnati is going to struggle to finish at 8-8, while Cleveland will lose double digit games again. 

AFC South

 

With the East and North both having two very good teams, there won’t be room for a Wildcard in this division.  Three teams sit tied at 4-2.  Houston’s defense will cost them a game or two down the stretch.  Tennessee and Indianapolis should decide this division in their head-to-head matchups.  We will go with the great Peyton Manning to pull off two close wins and give the Colts another division title at 11-5.  Jacksonville will more than likely be shopping for a new coach.  They should be shopping for a new city.  The Los Angeles Jaguars has a nice ring to it. 

AFC West

 

San Diego cannot win on the road, and the last time we checked, they have eight road games.  Denver has not started on fire this year and will not be 6-2 at the halfway point before they collapse in the second half.  Oakland is still a dozen quality players short, while Kansas City has shown just enough to lead this division.  We think the Chiefs could pull this off at 9-7. 

Our playoff Soothsayer sees this scenario:

 

NFC

1. Philadelphia

2. New Orleans

3. Minnesota

4. Seattle

W. Atlanta 

W. New York Giants 

AFC

1. New York Jets

2. Pittsburgh

3. Indianapolis

4. Kansas City

W. New England 

W. Baltimore 

 

Wildcard Round

New York Giants at Minnesota

Atlanta at Seattle 

Baltimore at Indianapolis

New England at Kansas City 

Divisional Round

 

Minnesota at Philadelphia

Seattle at New Orleans 

Indianapolis at Pittsburgh

New England at New York Jets

 

Conference Championship

New Orleans at Philadelphia

 

Pittsburgh at New York Jets 

SUPER BOWL

 

Philadelphia vs. Pittsburgh 

Winner: The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

 

This Week’s PiRate Passer Ratings 

Player	Team	Comp%	Int %	AYPA	PiRate #
Michael Vick	PHI	61.5	0.00	6.7	121.5
Peyton Manning	IND	67.3	0.79	6.9	115.7
Kyle Orton	DEN	62.8	1.21	6.7	110.8
Phillip Rivers	SD	62.3	2.27	7	103.2
Mark Sanchez	NYJ	55.4	1.13	5.1	102.6
Kevin Kolb	PHI	67.6	1.90	5.8	99.7
Jay Cutler	CHI	60.3	2.13	5.7	97.2
Vince Young	TEN	61.4	1.98	5.4	96.8
Seneca Wallace	CLE	63.0	2.00	5.4	96.6
Josh Freeman	TB	59.1	1.89	5.1	96.0
Matt Ryan	ATL	60.3	1.83	5	95.9
Tom Brady	NE	67.5	2.41	5.6	94.2
Donovan McNabb	WAS	58.1	2.33	5.4	93.8
Matt Schaub	HOU	64.5	2.54	5.7	93.6
Drew Brees	NO	70.6	2.60	5.7	93.1
Matt Cassel	KC	57.8	2.22	4.9	91.9
Ryan Fitzpatrick	BUF	61.2	2.35	4.9	90.7
Chad Henne	MIA	63.2	2.92	5.1	86.8
Joe Flacco	BAL	60.5	2.93	5.1	86.8
Tony Romo	DAL	69.4	3.40	5.7	86.0
Carson Palmer	CIN	59.3	3.09	4.8	83.7
Aaron Rodgers	GB	64.2	3.48	5.3	83.0
Shaun Hill	DET	61.1	3.37	4.4	79.0
Eli Manning	NYG	64.7	3.92	4.9	76.9
Matt Hasselbeck	SEA	61.4	3.61	4.2	75.7
Sam Bradford	STL	56.8	3.42	3.6	74.1
Bruce Gradkowski	OAK	52.0	3.92	4.3	73.6
Alex Smith	SF	60.1	4.04	4.1	71.4
Jimmie Clausen	CAR	47.3	3.30	2.6	69.5
Brett Favre	MIN	58.7	4.67	3.5	62.5
Derek Anderson	ARI	51.8	4.39	2.8	61.1
Jason Campbell	OAK	56.0	4.40	2.6	59.9
David Garrard	JAX	65.6	5.47	3.2	53.8
Charlie Batch	PIT	59.2	6.12	3.7	50.8
Trent Edwards	JAX	56.6	5.26	1.4	45.5
Jake Delhomme	CLE	55.0	6.67	2.2	37.7
Matt Moore	CAR	42.4	10.17	0.2	-4.4

 

The PiRate Passer Formula is: ((7* AYPA) – (11* Int.%)) +105] * 0.8

 

AYPA is Air Yards Per Pass Attempt or Passing Yards minus Yards After Catch. 

This statistic is available at advancednflstats.com

This Week’s NFL PiRate Ratings

NFC East	PiRate	Mean	Biased	W-L-T	PPG	Opp
Philadelphia Eagles	105.0	103.2	104.9	4-2-0	28.2	20.0
Dallas Cowboys	103.1	101.1	99.9	1-4-0	20.4	22.2
New York Giants	102.8	102.9	103.2	4-2-0	22.3	19.7
Washington Redskins	98.6	100.1	98.2	3-3-0	18.8	19.8
NFC North	PiRate	Mean	Biased	W-L-T	Pts	Opp
Minnesota Vikings	103.1	102.0	100.7	2-3-0	17.4	17.6
Green Bay Packers	102.4	102.6	100.7	3-3-0	23.2	18.7
Chicago Bears	98.9	100.1	99.5	4-2-0	18.7	16.2
Detroit Lions	96.5	98.6	93.9	1-5-0	24.3	23.3
NFC South	PiRate	Mean	Biased	W-L-T	Pts	Opp
New Orleans Saints	104.6	102.4	104.1	4-2-0	21.7	18.0
Atlanta Falcons	103.6	103.6	102.3	4-2-0	21.7	16.8
Carolina Panthers	97.1	92.2	89.8	0-5-0	10.4	22.0
Tampa Bay Buccaneers	92.6	95.4	96.7	3-2-0	16.0	22.2
NFC West	PiRate	Mean	Biased	W-L-T	Pts	Opp
Seattle Seahawks	97.4	97.3	98.6	3-2-0	19.6	19.4
San Francisco 49ers	97.1	95.6	95.8	1-5-0	16.3	23.2
St. Louis Rams	94.6	95.2	97.1	3-3-0	17.2	18.8
Arizona Cardinals	94.0	96.9	97.3	3-2-0	17.6	27.6
AFC East	PiRate	Mean	Biased	W-L-T	Pts	Opp
New York Jets	110.4	108.1	109.4	5-1-0	26.5	16.8
New England Patriots	106.4	106.1	107.0	4-1-0	30.8	23.2
Miami Dolphins	101.4	99.4	101.7	3-2-0	17.8	22.4
Buffalo Bills	91.6	90.5	88.9	0-5-0	17.4	32.6
AFC North	PiRate	Mean	Biased	W-L-T	Pts	Opp
Baltimore Ravens	106.5	106.0	107.6	4-2-0	18.7	15.8
Pittsburgh Steelers	105.4	107.9	106.6	4-1-0	22.8	12.0
Cincinnati Bengals	100.5	99.0	99.0	2-3-0	20.0	20.4
Cleveland Browns	95.2	95.8	94.9	1-5-0	14.7	20.8
AFC South	PiRate	Mean	Biased	W-L-T	Pts	Opp
Indianapolis Colts	105.1	105.5	105.4	4-2-0	27.2	20.8
Tennessee Titans	103.2	107.0	105.3	4-2-0	27.0	16.3
Houston Texans	100.3	98.7	102.5	4-2-0	25.5	27.8
Jacksonville Jaguars	92.5	93.9	97.6	3-3-0	18.3	27.8
AFC West	PiRate	Mean	Biased	W-L-T	Pts	Opp
San Diego Chargers	99.9	99.6	100.2	2-4-0	26.2	21.0
Kansas City Chiefs	99.6	99.6	100.7	3-2-0	21.6	18.4
Denver Broncos	97.6	99.6	97.3	2-4-0	20.7	23.3
Oakland Raiders	93.4	94.1	93.0	2-4-0	20.0	25.2

This Week’s PiRate, Mean, and Biased Spreads 

This Week’s Games
Home Team in CAPS	(N) Denotes Neutral Site
Week 7: October 24-25, 2010
Vegas Line as of 3:30 PM EDT Tuesday
Favorite	Underdog	PiRate	Mean	Bias	Vegas	Totals
Pittsburgh	MIAMI	2.0	6.5	2.9	3	40 ½
ATLANTA	Cincinnati	6.1	7.6	6.3	3 1/2	43
KANSAS CITY	Jacksonville	10.1	8.7	6.1	4 1/2	43
TENNESSEE	Philadelphia	1.2	6.8	3.4	3	44
CHICAGO	Washington	3.3	3.0	4.3	3	40
NEW ORLEANS	Cleveland	12.4	9.6	6.2	13	43
BALTIMORE	Buffalo	17.9	18.5	21.7	13	38
CAROLINA	San Francisco	2.0	-1.4	-4.0	-3	35
TAMPA BAY	St. Louis	0.0	2.2	1.6	3	38 ½
SEATTLE	Arizona	5.4	2.4	3.3	5 1/2	40 ½
New England	SAN DIEGO	2.5	2.5	2.8	-3	47
DENVER	Oakland	7.2	8.5	7.3	7	42 ½
GREEN BAY	Minnesota	2.3	2.6	3.0	2 1/2	44 ½
DALLAS	New York Giants	2.3	0.2	-1.3	3 1/2	44 ½